Denied Workers’ Comp Claim in Illinois? Here’s What to Do Next
You did the right thing by reporting your work injury and filing for workers’ compensation — but now your claim has been denied, disputed, or your employer refuses to file it at all. You’re hurt, bills are piling up, and you’re wondering: “Can they really do this? What do I do now?”
In Illinois, insurance companies and employers deny valid workers’ comp claims all the time. The good news: a denial is not the end of your case. You have rights, there are deadlines, and you can fight back — with the right evidence and an experienced Illinois workers’ compensation attorney on your side.
Get Help With Your Denied Workers’ Comp Claim
If you’re already facing medical bills, pain, and a claim denial, you don’t have to figure this out alone. An experienced Illinois workers’ compensation attorney can step in, deal with the insurance company, and explain your options. You pay nothing unless we recover, and no up front fees. Don’t wait – contact us today.
If your workers’ comp claim has been denied in Illinois, click here to talk with a lawyer and get a free case review today.
What It Really Means When Your Workers’ Comp Claim Is Denied
A denial simply means the workers’ compensation insurance company (or sometimes your employer) is refusing to pay your benefits right now. It does not automatically mean:
• Your injury isn’t real
• You did something wrong
• You’ve permanently lost your rights
In Illinois, it is very common for workers’ comp claims to be denied at first. Sometimes it’s because of a technical issue with notice or paperwork. Other times, it’s because the insurance company thinks it can save money by fighting your case and hoping you give up and do not seek the benefits you are entitled to.
A denial is often the beginning of the legal fight, not the end of your workers’ comp claim.
Common Reasons Workers’ Comp Claims Are Denied in Illinois
Understanding why your claim was denied tells you what you need to address in an appeal. Some of the most frequent denial reasons we see include:
Late or “defective” reporting
The insurance company may claim that:
• You did not report your injury to your employer within the 45-day notice period, or
• You did not complete the “right” forms the way they wanted
In reality, many workers tell a supervisor right away, but the employer delays or mishandles the report. In cumulative or repetitive trauma cases, the timeline is often tied to when you realized your condition was work-related, not the very first twinge of pain.
“Not work-related”
The insurer may argue that your injury or illness:
• Happened somewhere else
• Came from a hobby or off-duty activity
• Is too minor or too “unclear” to be considered a work injury
This is especially common with back, neck, shoulder, and repetitive motion injuries where there is no single dramatic accident. They may hide behind the statement that it’s denied while their “investigating.” Meanwhile, you’re not getting paid and in pain.
Pre-existing condition
Insurers frequently claim, “You already had this problem.”
They may argue that:
• Your condition is degenerative or age-related
• An old injury or arthritis is really to blame
• Your job did not make anything worse
Under Illinois law, you may still be entitled to workers’ compensation if your job aggravated, accelerated, or worsened a pre-existing condition. The question is not whether you were perfectly healthy before, but whether work made things significantly worse. We recently had two big wins at trial in exactly this type of situation. They denied the cases and we used expert testimony to fight this at trial, showing that the accident aggravated or worsened the pre-existing condition. Read more here. Don’t let them deny your benefits based on this!
“Insufficient medical evidence” or IME disputes
Sometimes the denial letter says there is not enough medical proof that:
• You are actually injured, or
• Your injury is connected to your job
In other cases, the insurance company sends you to an “independent” medical exam (IME), and that doctor’s opinion conflicts with your treating doctor. The insurer then uses the IME as an excuse to deny or cut off benefits. Or they send you to their company clinic who tells you you’re fine and can work without any restrictions. You have the right to see your own doctor in Illinois Workers’ Comp, and that doctor may be better suited to explain what the problem is and how it relates to work.
Alleged misconduct or being “outside the scope” of employment
The insurer may claim:
• You were breaking a safety rule
• You were under the influence of drugs or alcohol
• You were doing something outside your job duties when you were hurt
Even when there are allegations like these, you may still have a valid claim depending on the facts. Do not assume you are disqualified just because the insurance company says so.
If you’re already facing medical bills, pain, and a claim denial, you don’t have to figure this out alone. An experienced Illinois workers’ compensation attorney can step in, deal with the insurance company, and explain your options. Click here – we want to help.
Step-by-Step: What To Do After a Workers’ Comp Denial in Illinois
If your workers’ comp claim has been denied or your benefits suddenly stop, here are the key steps to take.
1. Get the denial in writing and read it carefully
Make sure you have the actual denial letter from the workers’ compensation insurance company, not just something your employer told you.
• Confirm that you have the letter
• Identify the specific reasons given for denial
• Note any important dates, deadlines, or instructions
Keep this letter in a safe place. You and your attorney will use it to build your strategy for appeal.
2. Keep getting medical treatment
Do not stop seeing your doctor, physical therapist, or specialist just because the insurance company said “no.” Gaps in treatment can hurt both your health and your claim.
Tell your doctor:
• That your workers’ comp claim was denied
• What reasons the insurer gave
• How your pain and limitations are affecting your work and daily life
Consistent medical care creates a clear record that your injury is ongoing and serious.
H3: 3. Gather your evidence
Start collecting every document and piece of information related to your injury:
• Medical records from before and after the injury
• Doctor’s notes, restrictions, and off-work slips
• Emergency room or urgent care records, if any
• Accident or incident reports at work
• Emails or texts where you reported the injury to a supervisor
• Names and contact information for coworkers who saw the incident or know the physical demands of your job
• Pay stubs and records showing lost wages or reduced hours
It is often helpful to create a simple timeline that shows:
• The date of the injury or when symptoms began
• When you first sought medical treatment
• When you reported the injury to your employer
• When you received the denial
The more organized your evidence is, the easier it is to prove your case.
H3: 4. Avoid common mistakes after a denial
After a workers’ comp denial, there are several mistakes that can seriously damage your claim. Try to avoid:
• Missing appeal or filing deadlines
• Stopping or “stretching out” your medical treatment
• Posting about your injury or activities on social media
• Giving recorded statements to the insurance company without legal advice
• Downplaying your symptoms to your doctor or your employer
• Signing forms or settlement papers you do not fully understand
If you are unsure about something, talk to a workers’ compensation attorney before you sign, post, or say anything that might end up in front of an arbitrator later.
H3: 5. Talk to an Illinois workers’ compensation attorney
Once a claim is denied, the insurance company is already treating your case as a legal dispute. You should too.
An experienced Illinois workers’ comp lawyer can:
• Explain what the denial really means in plain language
• Take over communications with the adjuster and insurance company
• Make sure all deadlines with the Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission are met
• Work with your doctors to strengthen the medical evidence
• Gather witness statements and other proof
• Prepare and present your case at a hearing
If your workers’ comp claim has been denied, call McHargue & Jones, LLC at (312) 739-0000 or contact us online. The consultation is free, and there is no fee unless we recover benefits for you (if that reflects your fee structure).
H2: Schedule Your Free Case Review (CTA)
Time matters after a denial. Evidence can be lost, memories fade, and deadlines can expire.
If you’re unsure what to do after a denied workers’ comp claim, click here to schedule your free case review with McHargue & Jones, LLC. We can review your denial letter, go over your rights under Illinois law, and outline a plan to move forward.
( → Link this line to your landing page / consultation form.)
H2: How the Workers’ Comp Appeal Process Works in Illinois
Illinois law provides a structured process for challenging a denied workers’ compensation claim. While every case is different, the basic stages often include:
H3: Filing an Application for Adjustment of Claim
If it has not already been filed, your lawyer will file an Application for Adjustment of Claim with the Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission (IWCC). This formally brings your dispute into the workers’ comp system.
In general, the time limits to file are:
• Three years from the date of injury, or
• Two years from the date you last received compensation benefits,
whichever is later, subject to the details of Illinois law and any exceptions that may apply.
H3: Preparing for a hearing before an arbitrator
Once your claim is on file, a workers’ compensation arbitrator will be assigned. Your attorney will:
• Obtain and review your medical records
• Work with your doctors to get clear written opinions on work-relatedness
• Collect accident reports, witness statements, and other documents
• Build a clear narrative and timeline of what happened and how you were affected
When the case is ready, you can request a hearing before the arbitrator.
H3: The arbitrator hearing
At the hearing:
• Your lawyer presents your testimony, medical records, and other evidence
• The insurance company and employer present their side
• The arbitrator considers all the evidence and the law
The arbitrator then issues a written decision, which may order the insurance company to pay benefits or may uphold the denial in whole or in part.
H3: Further appeals if needed
If the arbitrator’s decision is not favorable, you may have the right to further appeals, including:
• A review by a three-commissioner panel of the IWCC
• Appeal to the Illinois Circuit Court
• Appeal to the Illinois Appellate Court
• In rare cases, review by the Illinois Supreme Court
Most workers’ comp cases resolve before reaching the higher courts, but it is important to work with a lawyer who is prepared to take your case as far as necessary.
H2: What If Your Employer Refuses to File or Report the Workers’ Comp Claim?
Many workers search for answers to questions like “employer refuses to file workers comp claim” or “can an employer deny workers’ comp?”
Your employer is not allowed to simply block you from pursuing workers’ compensation benefits. If a boss or HR representative:
• Refuses to fill out an accident report
• Tells you to put the claim through your own health insurance instead
• Tries to discourage or threaten you for reporting an injury
You should:
• Put your report in writing (email or text is fine) so there is a record
• See a doctor and clearly explain that you were injured at work
• Contact an Illinois workers’ compensation attorney who can file the case with the IWCC even if your employer will not cooperate
Do not let an uncooperative employer convince you that you do not have a case. You still have legal options.
Do I Still Have a Case if I Have a Pre-Existing Condition?
Yes, you may. A pre-existing condition does not automatically disqualify you from workers’ comp in Illinois.
You may still have a valid claim if:
• Your job duties aggravated or accelerated your condition
• Your symptoms became significantly worse after a specific accident or period of repetitive work
• You needed new or increased treatment because of your job
Key evidence in these cases includes:
• Medical records that compare your condition before and after the work injury
• A clear doctor’s opinion connecting your worsening condition to your job duties
Insurance companies often blame everything on age or prior injuries. An experienced workers’ comp attorney can help you and your doctor frame the evidence so an arbitrator can see how work truly affected your health.
How to Strengthen Your Denied Workers’ Comp Claim
Whether your claim was denied for “late reporting,” “pre-existing condition,” “not work-related,” or lack of evidence, you can usually improve your chances on appeal by:
• Getting consistent medical treatment and following your doctors’ orders
• Making sure your doctors understand your job duties and how the injury happened
• Asking your doctor to clearly state in writing whether your job caused or aggravated your condition
• Collecting witness statements from coworkers who saw the accident or know the physical demands of your job
• Keeping a detailed record of your symptoms, time off work, and restrictions
• Avoiding social media posts and casual comments that could be misunderstood
The more complete and consistent your evidence is, the stronger your case becomes.
When Should I Call a Lawyer About a Denied Workers’ Comp Claim?
You should speak with an Illinois workers’ compensation attorney as soon as:
• You receive a written denial or “dispute” of your claim
• Your employer refuses to file or report your claim
• Your checks suddenly stop or your treatment is cut off
• The insurance company blames a pre-existing condition or says your injury is not work-related
The earlier you involve an attorney, the easier it is to protect deadlines, preserve evidence, and build a strong appeal.
Talk to a Chicago Lawyer About Your Denied Workers’ Comp Claim
A denied workers’ compensation claim can be frightening and frustrating, but it is not the final word. Many valid claims are initially denied and later approved, settled, or won at hearing once the evidence is properly developed.
McHargue & Jones, LLC has decades of experience fighting for injured workers in Chicago and throughout Illinois. We know how insurance companies think, and we know how to respond.
If your Illinois workers’ comp claim has been denied or disputed for any reason, click here to contact our Chicago workers’ compensation attorneys and schedule your free consultation today.
Call us at (312) 739-0000 or contact us online. We can review your denial, explain your options, and fight to get you the benefits you deserve.
