Why is My Workers’ Compensation Claim Being Denied?
In Illinois, workers’ compensation claims are denied every day — often even when the worker has a legitimate injury. Most denials are based on disputes over whether the injury is work-related, whether the worker can return to work, or whether the requested medical treatment (such as surgery) is “necessary.”
A denial does not mean you are ineligible for benefits. It usually means the insurance company is refusing to pay without being forced to do so. Illinois law allows injured workers to challenge denied claims, present medical evidence, and request hearings before the Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission.
Common denial issues include alleged paperwork defects, claims of pre-existing conditions, delayed reporting, and disputes over medical causation — all of which can often be overcome with proper documentation and legal action.
If your claim or treatment has been denied, these in-depth guides explain what to do next:
Common Reasons Why Workers’ Comp Claims Are Denied In Illinois
1. Disputes Over Whether the Injury Is Work-Related
Insurance companies often deny claims by arguing the injury did not “arise out of and in the course of employment.” This is common in:
-
repetitive trauma injuries,
-
aggravations of prior injuries,
-
injuries without witnesses, or
-
conditions that develop over time.
These denials are frequently contested with medical opinions and testimony.
2. Claims That You Can Return to Work
Even when an injury is real, insurers may argue that:
-
you can work light duty,
-
restrictions are exaggerated, or
-
disability has ended.
These arguments are commonly used to terminate wage benefits such as temporary total disability (TTD).
3. Denial of Medical Treatment or Surgery
It is common for workers’ comp insurers to accept that an injury occurred but deny:
-
surgery,
-
injections,
-
physical therapy,
-
or specialist referrals.
These denials are often based on utilization review opinions and can be challenged.
4. Pre-Existing Conditions
A claim may be denied if the insurer alleges your condition existed before work injury. Under Illinois law, an aggravation of a pre-existing condition is compensable, but insurers often force workers to prove it through medical evidence.
5. Late Reporting or Alleged Notice Problems
Claims are sometimes denied because the employer alleges the injury was not reported promptly. Late notice does not automatically defeat a claim, but it often leads to disputes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a denied workers’ comp claim mean I lose my rights?
No. A denial simply means the insurer is refusing to pay voluntarily. Many Illinois workers’ comp claims are denied initially and later approved through hearings or settlement.
How do I appeal a denied workers’ comp claim in Illinois?
You may file an Application for Adjustment of Claim with the Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission and request a hearing. Strict deadlines apply, so delays can harm your case.
Can workers’ comp deny benefits because of a pre-existing condition?
Not automatically. Illinois workers can receive benefits when work activity aggravates or accelerates a pre-existing condition, even if symptoms existed before.
What if workers’ comp denies my surgery but accepts the injury?
This is common. Treatment denials can be challenged through utilization review disputes, medical testimony, and hearings before the Commission.
How long do I have to challenge a denial?
Time limits depend on the date of injury and last payment of benefits. Waiting too long can bar your claim entirely.
When should I talk to a lawyer?
If your claim, medical treatment, or wage benefits are denied, it usually means the insurer will not pay without a legal fight. Early guidance can protect both benefits and settlement value.