What Is a Hernia Settlement Worth in Illinois Workers’ Comp?

If you suffered a hernia at work in Illinois, you’ve probably heard anything from “it’s worth nothing” to “you should get a big settlement.” The truth is in the middle:

• Many straightforward hernia claims settle in the $5,000–$25,000 range.

• When the hernia becomes complex, with multiple surgeries, a very weak abdominal wall, and permanent restrictions, I’ve obtained multiple six-figure settlements based on future wage loss and loss of occupation, not just a “hernia rating.”

This article walks through how Illinois workers’ comp treats hernias, what drives case value, and when a “small” hernia turns into a life-changing claim.

---

Quick Answer: How Much Is a Hernia Worth in Illinois Workers’ Comp?

There is no fixed chart that says “hernia = $X.” Your settlement depends on:

• Your wages (average weekly wage)

• How serious the hernia and surgery are

• Whether you fully recover or have permanent restrictions

• Whether you can return to your old job or lose your trade

As a very general guide:

• Routine hernia claims that heal well and don’t change your job:

  • Common settlement range: about $5,000–$25,000

• Complex hernia claims with recurrent hernias, multiple surgeries, weak abdominal wall, and permanent restrictions that cost you your occupation:

  • These cases can reach six figures, based largely on your lost future earnings and loss of occupation, not just a simple impairment percentage.

Every case is different. The same hernia in a low-wage, light-duty job is worth something very different than the same hernia in a high-wage, heavy-labor job.  Click here to learn more about factors that may impact your workers’ comp settlement.

---

Are Hernias Covered Under Illinois Workers’ Compensation?

Yes. In Illinois, hernias are covered injuries if they arise out of and in the course of your employment.  You do not have to prove fault or negligence.

That means if your job caused or aggravated your hernia, workers’ comp should cover:

• All reasonable and necessary medical care

• Wage loss while you’re off work

• Permanent disability if you’re left with lasting problems or restrictions

There is no requirement that your employer did anything “wrong.” Illinois workers’ comp is a no-fault system.

---

Common Work Situations That Cause Hernias

I see hernias in a wide range of jobs, including:

• Construction and trades (lifting materials, tools, equipment)

• Warehouse, shipping, and logistics (boxes, pallets, freight)

• Healthcare (lifting or repositioning patients)

• Manufacturing and factory work

• Delivery drivers and movers

Typical stories I hear:

• “I lifted a heavy box and felt a pop in my belly.”

• “I’ve been lifting all day for years, but this time it hurt immediately.”

• “I twisted pulling something and felt burning pain in my abdomen.”

If the hernia started or got significantly worse because of what you do at work, it’s usually worth exploring a claim.

---

What Benefits Can You Get for a Work-Related Hernia in Illinois?

In an Illinois hernia case, we typically look at four categories of benefits.

1. Medical Bills

Workers’ comp should pay for:

• ER or urgent care visits

• Imaging (ultrasound, CT scan, MRI)

• Hernia repair surgery (open or laparoscopic, with or without mesh)

• Follow-up visits, physical therapy, pain management

• Medication related to the hernia

You should not have co-pays or out-of-pocket medical bills for covered treatment.

---

2. Temporary Total Disability (TTD) – Wage Loss While You’re Off Work

If your doctor takes you completely off work, you may be entitled to Temporary Total Disability (TTD).

• TTD is generally 2/3 of your average weekly wage

• It’s paid tax-free while you’re off work because of the hernia

• It stops when you return to work, are released to full duty, or your case reaches a different stage

Internal link spot:
“How much does workers’ comp pay in TTD?” → link to your TTD explainer post.

---

3. Light Duty and Temporary Partial Disability (TPD)

If your employer offers light duty and your doctor allows it:

• You may have restrictions like “no lifting over 20 lbs,” “no repetitive bending,” or “no climbing.”

• If you earn less on light duty than before the injury, you may be entitled to Temporary Partial Disability (TPD), usually 2/3 of the difference between old and new wages.

Internal link spot:
“Types of benefits in Illinois workers’ comp” → link to your benefits breakdown post.

---

4. Permanent Disability or Wage Differential

This is where the value of a hernia case can change dramatically.

Once you reach Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI) (your condition has plateaued), we look at permanent impact:

• If you heal well, return to your regular job, and have only mild symptoms:

  • Your case is usually resolved as a Permanent Partial Disability (PPD) settlement.

  • That’s where many hernia cases fall in the $5,000–$25,000 range (depending on wages, age, and residual issues).

• If things go badly, and you’re left with a weak abdominal wall and permanent restrictions, your case may be worth far more.

  Serious hernia outcomes often include:

  • Recurrent hernias

  • Multiple surgeries with mesh and scar tissue

  • Restrictions like “no lifting over 10–20 lbs,” “no repetitive bending/twisting,” or “sedentary only”

  • A doctor saying you cannot safely go back to your prior heavy-duty job

In those cases, your claim may be evaluated as a wage differential or loss-of-occupation case, where the settlement or award is based on:

• The gap between what you used to earn and what you can earn now, multiplied over many years, or

• A lump-sum settlement that realistically accounts for future lost wages and loss of your trade

That’s how a hernia that looked “minor” at first can become a six-figure case.  Most hernia cases thankfully don’t result in life changing restrictions, but you don’t know this when it first happens.  That’s why it’s a good idea to consult a lawyer early.

---

Why Hernia Workers’ Comp Cases Get Undervalued

Insurance companies tend to treat hernias as small, routine injuries. Common problems I see:

• Lowball offers based only on a small PPD percentage

• Pushing a quick settlement before your true restrictions are known

• Ignoring your loss of trade if you can’t safely return to heavy-labor work

• Telling workers “hernia cases aren’t worth anything” or “Illinois doesn’t pay for hernias”

Those statements are wrong in Illinois. Hernias are compensable, and when they leave you with permanent limitations, your case is about your future, not just the scar on your belly.

---

Factors That Drive What Your Hernia Case Is Worth

When I evaluate a hernia case, I look closely at the following factors:

1. Average Weekly Wage (AWW)
   Higher wages = higher TTD and higher permanent disability value.

2. Type and Number of Surgeries
   One simple repair vs. multiple recurrent repairs and abdominal wall reconstruction are not the same.

3. Permanent Restrictions
   Written restrictions from your surgeon (e.g., no lifting over 20 lbs, no repetitive bending, sedentary work only) are crucial.

4. Ability to Return to Your Old Job

   • Can you go back to construction, warehouse work, nursing, or other heavy-labor jobs?

   • Or are you forced into lighter work at lower pay—or out of the workforce?

5. Age and Work History
   A younger worker who permanently loses a high-pay trade has a much larger lifetime wage loss.

6. Future Medical Needs
   Risk of recurrence, potential future surgeries, and ongoing pain management can all affect case value.

---

What If I Had a Hernia Before I Got Hurt at Work?

A “pre-existing” hernia does not automatically kill your claim.

Under Illinois law, if your job aggravates, accelerates, or worsens a pre-existing condition, that can still be a valid workers’ comp case.

Examples:

• You had a small, painless hernia for years

• Your job requires heavy lifting

• One day you feel a pop and now the hernia is much larger and painful, requiring surgery

That’s often still a compensable case. The key is connecting your worsening condition to your work activities.

---

Do You Need a Lawyer for a Hernia Workers’ Comp Case?

You might get through a truly simple case on your own:

• The claim is accepted

• Surgery is promptly approved

• TTD is paid correctly

• You make a good recovery

• You return to your job with no lasting limits

But you absolutely should talk to a lawyer if:

• Your hernia claim is denied or questioned as “not work-related”

• Surgery is delayed or denied

• You have a recurrent hernia or multiple surgeries

• Your doctor is talking about permanent restrictions or a career change

• The insurance company is pushing a quick settlement that doesn’t feel right

An experienced Illinois workers’ comp lawyer can:

• Make sure all benefits (medical, TTD, PPD/wage differential) are correctly calculated

• Protect your right to future medical care where appropriate

• Frame your case as a loss-of-occupation / future wage loss case when the facts support it

• Push back against lowball offers that treat a complex hernia like a “minor” claim

Workers’ comp lawyers usually charge a 20% fee, and you do not pay any fees unless they recover.  Learn more here – you can absolutely afford to hire an attorney.

---

What Happens If the Insurance Company Won’t Pay Fairly?

If your employer or their insurer won’t do the right thing voluntarily, your case can be filed and litigated before an arbitrator at the Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission.

An arbitrator can decide:

• Whether your hernia is work-related

• Whether your current condition is related to the work accident

• What medical, TTD, and permanent benefits you’re entitled to

Their decision can be appealed within the Commission and, if necessary, into the court system. This is where having a lawyer who understands complex hernia cases and future wage loss really matters.

---

FAQ: Hernia Settlements in Illinois Workers’ Comp

1. What is the average workers’ comp settlement for a hernia in Illinois?

There’s no true “average,” but many straightforward, well-healed hernia cases land somewhere around $5,000–$25,000, depending on wages and medical recovery. Cases with multiple surgeries, permanent restrictions, and loss of occupation can be worth significantly more, including six-figure settlements in the right circumstances.

---

2. Can a hernia workers’ comp case in Illinois be worth six figures?

Yes. When a hernia causes long-term problems—multiple surgeries, a very weak abdominal wall, permanent lifting restrictions, and loss of a high-wage, heavy-labor job—settlements can reach six figures because they’re based on future lost earnings and loss of your trade, not just the cost of surgery.

---

3. Does Illinois workers’ comp pay for hernia surgery?

If your hernia is found to be work-related, Illinois workers’ comp should cover all reasonable and necessary medical care, including hernia repair surgery, follow-up, therapy, and related medications. You should not be using your personal health insurance or paying co-pays for approved work-related care.

---

4. How long does a hernia workers’ comp claim take to settle?

Timing varies. Simple cases may resolve within months of finishing treatment. Cases with disputes (denied surgery, causation fights, multiple surgeries, permanent restrictions, vocational issues) can take longer, especially if they go to hearing. Rushing to settle before your condition and restrictions are clear can cost you serious money.

---

5. Do I have to report my hernia right away?

In Illinois, you generally have 45 days to report a work injury, but you should tell your employer as soon as you know something is wrong. Waiting makes it easier for the insurance company to argue that your hernia is not work-related.

---

6. What if the insurance company says my hernia isn’t work-related?

That’s a common pushback. They may blame your age, weight, lifestyle, or a “pre-existing condition.” You don’t have to accept that. A lawyer can work with your doctors, obtain medical opinions, and present your case to an arbitrator at the Illinois Workers’ Compensation Commission if necessary.

---

7. Should I settle my hernia case before I know my permanent restrictions?

Generally, no. Settling before your surgeon has clearly identified whether you need permanent restrictions and before you know whether you can return to your old job is risky. If you sign away your case and later find out you can’t do your prior work, you may have left a large amount of money on the table.

---

Hernia at Work in Chicago? Get a Free Case Review.

If you’ve had a hernia at work in Illinois—especially if you’re facing recurrent hernias, multiple surgeries, a very weak abdominal wall, or permanent restrictions—you should get a personalized case review before you settle.

Injured at Work in Chicago? Get a Free Workers’ Comp Case Review.

Click Here to Start Your Free Case Review →

Tap to call: (312) 739-0000